Maybe that's what Heather really needed, Paul

zara's picture

It's getting better all the time
I used to get mad at my school
The teachers who taught me weren't cool
You're holding me down, turning me round
Filling me up with your rules.

I've got to admit it's getting better
A little better all the time
I have to admit it's getting better
It's getting better since you've been mine.

Me used to be a angry young man
Me hiding me head in the sand
You gave me the word
I finally heard
I'm doing the best that I can.
I've got to admit it's getting better
I used to be cruel to my woman
I beat her and kept her apart from the things that she loved
Man I was mean but I'm changing my scene
And I'm doing the best that I can.

I admit it's getting better
A little better all the time
Yes I admit it's getting better
It's getting better since you've been mine




I found myself singing this song today as I was driving to see Stardust with my sister. I idly sang along, like most people who have been exposed to The Beatles usually do. We all know the lyrics in that uniform way that we know lyrics. It's no different singing a Beatles' tune than it is singing "Twinkle Twinkle Little Star." You sing it and you don't really pay attention.

I wonder if that's what singing hymns are like. But I dye grass...

It came to the point later in the song that I've highlighted above and I thought to myself, "That must be a Lennon song." When I came home, I researched it and discovered that the two had worked together to come up with the music and lyrics, but the lyrics were from McCartney.

(As an aside, it just now occurred to me that my friend Paul's girlfriend's name is Heather. Mildly amusing.)

I know there are lines in songs all over the universal playlist of life, ones that strike you for their bold and ignorant or idiotic phrasing. It's just somehow odd to me that the dim approval of domestic abuse is in a Beatles song. Aren't they supposed to be the safe musicians? The ones that people can listen to with their children? Hell, I know I spent many an evening around the turntable when I was a little girl, listening to my dad play me record after record and explain why I needed to love it.

Then I started thinking about all that crap that (had or has, who knows and who honestly cares anymore?) happened with the Paul McCartney/Heather Mills divorce. If there was anyone who honestly thought that she married him (and subsequently went through invitro fertilization in order to produce a child) for love, well... I'm sure I could easily talk you out of your credit card number, you bumbling moron.

But hearing that line and finding out that he'd written the lyric made me pause. I'd laughed at her accusations that he'd been "cruel" to her and "abusive." Funny what rich and privileged people find to be cruel and abusive, you know? But who knows? Maybe Sir Paul actually was mean to the poor legless woman. Not that I'd really care one way or the other.

I don't think domestic abuse is condoned behaviour. I'm just saying that for all the show that people can put on about how much they care about what happens to other people, we don't. We empathize but we don't want to be in their shoes. We all want to smile and live our own little lives, filled with our own trite drama. If we've been in an abusive relationship in the past, we might rally against musicians who write lines like that. But very, very few people actually do anything productive about it.

We don't donate to abused women's shelters. We don't give money to the organizations that help kids from these families get the psychological help that they need. We don't do anything that helps the big picture.

And don't start with the "I let a friend live with me" stuff. You'd let a friend in need live with you if they'd lost their house in a fire too. They're your friend (or a family member) and that's not the point. My point is that everyone walks around in their own personal bubbles. Only they don't want to admit it and those who do get roasted for being self-aware.

We allow subjective material where women are perceived as tangible objects prevail in media images. We raise our boys to not cry and we treat our girls like they "shouldn't" do certain things because they're not "ladylike." And we practically run up and gouge the eyes out of the people who go against these theories. We're in the classic fucked if we do and fucked if we don't situation.

To which I say... fuck it. Don't feel bad about being preoccupied with yourself. Don't feel bad that you don't feel bad when you sing gaily about some man who'd formerly beaten his woman and segregated her from the things that were dearest to her but now that he's knocked that off, things are A-OK!

Confliction is the name of my game, dude.

Comments

I've got to agree, why the

I've got to agree, why the fuck should we care? It really dosen't concern us in the slightest if Paul, or John, or anyone else for that matter smacked their bitch up. That's between the prepetrator and the LE officer that should be called and if the victim dosen't wish to enlist the aid of the Law then fuck them all to hell, they get what's coming to them. I couldn't give a fuck less about someone who won't help themselves.

lrk1977's picture

You attitude

is exactly why domestic violence is still prevalent in homes today. I could go into the why's and how's, but my guess is that you wouldn't care or really listen.

People like you make me sick to my stomach. You could make a difference if actually gave a damn.

Lesley from Minnesota :)

You clearly don't understand

I'VE BEEN THERE. I've been the one abused, by one of my parents and my ex-spouse. I've been the one who thought that if I loved that person enough that they would stop. I've been the one who blamed myself for their actions. I've been that person. I haven't just worked with them.

You assume that I wouldn't care? On the contrary. I would love to care, but I've seen too many people who wouldn't do a fucking thing to help themselves. They, like I once did, blamed themselves, they lied for their abuser, they tried to hide the bruises. I say fuck that. I will never again be the willing victim. I will never again put myself in that place.

People like you make me sick because you talk out of your asses about things that you have no first hand experience. I say that we need to teach our children that any abuse is too much. That they never have to live with that. I have a daughter and I can assure you she will never stand idly by and be a victim.

You could make a difference if you could get through to these people by telling them the truth and not sugar coating anything. If you stay in a situation of increasing abuse there is a likely hood that you will die. That's the truth. If you're so stupid that you deny that for what ever reason then you deserve what you get.

If you know someone in this situation tell them to get out and get out now. Abusers don't change, they don't get better, they may come to realize the consequences but in that moment of anger they won't care to think they'll do what comes natural to them and that is to hurt.

Sadly what some people need is to be hurt to realize all that, and as much as I wish that wern't true it is and the fault lies with the victim, if they go back into the situation, or don't report it.

Your Attitude

Is why there is so much spousal abuse.

You need a good backhander to keep you in line.

It's not funny

we can all sit here on our computers and bullshit about it but it's not.

dawn61036's picture

I hope someone beats your

I hope someone beats your mother, daughter, or sister so badly on a daily basis that she is scared for her life to ask anyone for help. Maybe then you will be forced to get a fucking clue.

No. I apologize, really I do. I would never hope that on any woman (or man)...I just wanted to get you to get a point. But the sad fact is I don't think people like you will EVER get a clue.

What I really hope is you get fleas from a dead animal on places your fat arms cant reach to scratch - YOU ARE a waste of space.

Peace Love & many Smiles...Dawn

lrk1977's picture

You're ignorant -

I have worked with domestic and sexual abuse and you obviously know nothing and are trying to just stir the pot to be an ass. Considering you have only been a member to this site for the day, I honestly don't hold much to who you are or your opinion. So shut up and sit down, pls.

Lesley from Minnesota :)

Well I might be new to this

Well I might be new to this stupid site, but that doesn't make me any less that you. You don't get a badge for belonging to a shitty website last i checked.

Besides me and Zara go way back to the early 90's when she used to blow homeless bums for cigarette money. I got her off the streets.

I guess that you've worked with some people makes you more qualified to post stuff on the internet. I just thought a professional would be .. I don't know .. intelligent or something.

Holy gosh, this was boring

I tried to read it but i started to doze off.

I awoke several hours later from the deepest sleep anyone has ever had.

I cannot thank you, or the banal commenter's enough.

Thanks for the puerile gloop,

Love Crabby

Budo7's picture

Having been homeless

and having had it "all" before I became homeless, (I now have everything I need) I learned a lot. People get what they get for a reason, I ain't saying it's a great reason, but before I was homeless, I would rather spit at you before I looked at you. I did not give 2 shits about anything or anyone, but me. I was the shizzle, (in my mind) the rude awakening of not being the shizzle, to living out of my car or in the woods, taught me what really is important in life.

Don't live in fear of anything. If you can do that, nothing and no one can have any control over you.

lrk1977's picture

In my limited experience

In working with domestic violence, sexual assault and homelessness there are about 10% of people who give 100% to help others. It is amazing to me how the man driving the Escalade doesn't have the cash to give, but the man driving the old beat up Town and Country with three kids in the back can give $200 to help those in need.

When I was a coach, I made my kids serve at the Gospel Mission - serving one meal to those in need really brought them down to earth. I challenge those of you who think you have it rough to serve a meal at your local shelter or soup kitchen - look those people in the eye, serve them their food and realize many are no different than yourself. Most Americans are only two paychecks away from poverty. Seriously.

I watch the MTV My Sweet Sixteen or VH1's Fabulous Weddings and it makes me sick - not sick because they have money, but sick because they blow their money on such stupid shit. Money that could go to help others. Do you really need to have custom made furniture for your reception or after party? Do you really have to have an ice sculpture? What is wrong with us that we are willing to spend a ton of money on shit that will be thrown away the next day rather than helping our fellow man?

Hahaha - sorry, you got me on a bad morning! RAWR! Volunteering and doing what I can in my community is one of my passions. :)

Lesley from Minnesota :)

jomadd's picture

2 things

1. Heather clearly married for the money. If you marry for money you learn very quickly that you earn every penny. It is the fucking you get for the fuckin you got. I have no simpathy

2. I think we dont care because we have all had friends in abusive relationships that couldnt be talked out of them. Everyone has said "you deserve better" and gotten the brilliant response "but I love 'em". Ok, so love em till they kill you. If that is their choice, so be it.

I know there is a #3 in here somewhere.....maybe later

sole's picture

I am at a loss

as to how to deal with domestic violence as a social epidemic. On the one had, as you know I was in an abusive relationship for seven years. I was always scared, in deep denial, concerned for my family's well-being if they found out, and mainly concerned with keeping my shameful secret under wraps. There were days when I would call in sick to work because the makeup could cover the bruises but not the swelling. My ex-husband was physically abusive as well as emotionally, and extremely controlling. He refused to get a job and I was forced to support us, while he hung out, used drugs and cheated on me all day. I'm not writing any of this to get anyone to feel sorry for me. I don't want anyone's pity. I don't feel sorry for myself and I really am over it.

For a long time after I got out of that situation, I was disgusted with myself. I was ashamed that I could let another person take so much control over me and that I allowed it to happen in the first place. I grew up with parents who were very strict, quick to hit, and extremely controlling, but I don't blame them for what I put myself through. I've blocked out a lot of bad memories from my marriage, but what I may never forget was that sinking feeling I would get in the pit of my stomach when I could sense he was itching for a fight - that intense feeling of dread, knowing what was to come (or worse yet, not knowing) for the next several hours. People often asked me later what I had done to provoke the violence. Seriously. What had I done to set him off? Do people honestly think that a woman nags her abusive husband into hitting her? That she crowds him and invades his space? That she flirts with other men in front of him? And this drives him to violence? Please. The sad part is that I've encountered such thickheaded ignorance on on more occasions than I care to remember.

So let me tell people from the perspective of someone who lived it. A battered woman is broken. She lives to keep the peace, silently going through the motions, every day of her life. Constantly aware that any little thing will set him off. What will it be next time? When will it happen again? Never raising her voice, and not meeting his eyes when she sees that vein on the side of his neck pulsating. He once turned the steering wheel violently while I was driving up an offramp. My car skidded down the embankment and ended up neatly on the side of the freeway. If I believed in god, I would think she kept me safe that day, but the truth is, shit goes down the way it does and that's that. This was definitely not the worst or most violent thing he ever did to me. And for some reason, I always felt sorry for him. A part of me wanted to take care of him, to fix him (because he was broken too) and to sacrifice myself for my love. In retrospect, this goes along with my Catholic upbringing, but I won't blame religion for my own mistakes either. I was young, dumb and deluded. And I had some serious self-esteem issues. And I was in it for the long run until one day I just woke up and decided it was over.

The part that I am at a loss over is how to help people who are going through this. Not every woman finds her strength. Not many women are able to fix themselves after being broken for so long. The abuse infiltrates your brain and controls how you feel about yourself. I actually tried to help a couple of friends who were in abusive relationships of their own after my divorce and both of them went back. They did not have to, there were no children involved, they weren't even married. They just chose to go back to their personal hell, and I in turn chose to end both friendships. I did not want to judge them, but I lost all respect for both of them. And that is what the majority of battered women end up doing. How can we help them if they won't help themselves? I'm sure if I had been offered help before I was ready to go, I would not have accepted it. For some reason, you believe that this person loves you and will change, even though common sense dictates otherwise. The mentality of a battered woman is almost such that she believes she deserves the abuse. Putting up with it almost makes you feel that your suffering will bring about some kind of reward (again with the Catholic indoctrination) but it never does.

So anyway, it's late and I'm rambling. I forgot what my point was and I'm not sure that I got it out. On a side note, a teacher of mine once went on a diatribe against calling men's undershirts "wife beaters." He could not understand how people (especially women) could throw around that term so freely and not be offended by it. In all honesty, I was never offended by the term because I never took it personally. It is more of a description of the type of men who traditionally wear these shirts than it is of the act of actually beating someone. Even after seeing it from his perspective, I don't take offense to it.

*Sole*

jomadd's picture

Wow

I am always amazed at how open you are.

While I am sorry for you experience, I am grateful that you recognize your power in the situation and when you were done, then you were done.

As a man it would be nice to find that thing to fix our side of the problem. Alas, I think we will just have to let it play out and help those who want it.

If you dont understand "wife beater t-shirts" just watch Cops. That would explain it to anyone.

Right

You're right. We dont(care). And Dont(should). ....You forgot to mention that ALL women are whores...;) it just hit me with the creditcard line.... You know, I do not carry plastic. I pay willingly $8 in your currency (or so) for handling every bill across the counter. Try talk me out of that.

I am sure you have experienced how you can make someone become interessted in you,online, because you are somewhat good at writing? Well, what they fall "in love" with, is much likely to be an imaginary - way out of porportion - picture of who could come up with such good stuff? Something entirely inside their own head. If they have a vivid enough imagination, they will make time for you. They will change their lifes to make time for you, just because of something you wrote. Like I do just know, because of what you wrote. I have no idea why. I guess i like to express myself as well sometimes.

We live in and out of illusions. I been thinking about how it could be stopped. And I have come short. I think if I started to tell the truth, I would be banned from the internet. Theres a really good chance he was abusive, allthough I dont know anything about her or the divorce shit. But extremly many relations are in fact absusive. And abuse is not only violence and or sexual abuse. There are many lesser forms, like women make use of for instance. Maybe she was nagging at him, when he wanted to stay up at night doing his thing. Beeing creative, writing a song or whatever. Thats is one form of abuse as well. I have gotten it from my spouse, and it IS abuse as well, to not allow your partner the space he needs to himself.

Lack of energy. When you have exhausted your energy, either from working to hard, living to rough, thinking to much, worrying or being sick or whatever, you tend to snap easier. Even you are otherwise a nice guy. Maybe there should be a law against taking good care of yourself. And what is that anyway. Take that one step further, and you may realize that while we tend to think we live in the best part of the world, in reality this is far from true. Rather we live in the best supported lie ever created. Cause while it is technically easy to have a good health and enough energy, stamina and selfcontrol, to take shit from someone you love and swallow it, to stop a fight from turn fast into abuse, in reality, this is not what happens.